2nd.MD is a good service if your employer or health plan offers it: it is usually free to you, and a nurse helps get your records together. Two things send people looking for an alternative. Their plan doesn’t include it, or they want to choose the surgeon instead of having one recommended.
How 2nd.MD works
- Access: it is a benefit through eligible employers and health plans, at no extra cost to members who have it.
- Intake: you describe your concern to a 2nd.MD nurse, who decides whether a second opinion fits, collects your records and recommends a specialist from its panel.
- The consult: by video or phone.
If your benefits include it, start there. Check your plan’s benefits site or ask HR.
If you don’t have 2nd.MD
- Cleveland Clinic MyConsult: $1,690 for a written report, $1,990 with a video visit. Cleveland Clinic matches you with the physician.
- NYU Langone orthopedic second opinion: $800 for an orthopedic surgeon’s written report with up to 5 questions, usually within 5 business days. NYU selects the doctor, and it is not offered in 12 states.
- UChicago Medicine: from $750 for a written opinion and a call with the physician. You choose the specialty.
- Your own insurance: Medicare Part B covers an in-person second surgical opinion before non-emergency surgery, and many plans do too.
More on prices in How much does an MRI second opinion cost?
If you want to pick the surgeon
With 2nd.MD and the hospital programs, someone else chooses or recommends the doctor. If you care who reads your scan, that matters.
BoneArc Second Opinion is an orthopedic marketplace. You browse surgeons’ profiles, see what each one focuses on, their turnaround and the price they set, and choose. You get a signed written opinion on the X-ray, MRI or CT you already have, plus one follow-up question. It is a written opinion, not an exam or a diagnosis.
Employers and health plans can also offer BoneArc Second Opinion to their members. See BoneArc Second Opinion for employers.
Quick answers
Can I buy 2nd.MD on my own?
2nd.MD is offered through employers and health plans. We did not find a direct-purchase price on 2nd.MD's own pages.
Does 2nd.MD let you choose your specialist?
A 2nd.MD nurse reviews your case and recommends a specialist from its panel.
What is the cheapest orthopedic second opinion without insurance?
Among programs that publish a price, UChicago starts at $750 and NYU Langone is $800. On BoneArc, each surgeon sets their own price and shows it on their profile.
Want a surgeon to look at your scan?
BoneArc Second Opinion is a written opinion from an orthopedic surgeon on the X-ray, MRI or CT you already have. It is opening soon. Join the free waitlist and we will email you when it opens in your state.
Join the BoneArc Second Opinion waitlist →Sources
- 2nd.MD member FAQ
- Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan: 2nd.MD for employers
- Cleveland Clinic MyConsult
- NYU Langone Orthopedic Second Opinion Service
- UChicago Medicine remote second opinions
- Medicare.gov: second surgical opinions
