If a surgeon has recommended an operation on your back or neck, a second opinion is one of the most useful things you can get. Spine recommendations vary between surgeons, and most common back problems have a nonsurgical path worth understanding first.
Most herniated disks don’t need surgery
The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons says that even though a herniated disk can be very painful, most people feel better within a few weeks or months without surgery, and only a small share need an operation. Surgery is usually recommended after nonsurgical treatment hasn’t helped, or sooner for muscle weakness, trouble walking, or loss of bladder or bowel control.
Those last symptoms are urgent. New loss of bladder or bowel control, or weakness that is getting worse, needs to be seen right away, not by a written opinion.
How often second opinions disagree
A prospective study in Brazil followed 485 people who had been recommended spine surgery and got a second opinion. The second opinion disagreed with the first diagnosis for 59.8% of them. In the end only 15.5% received the same surgical recommendation they started with, and 55.3% were advised to try nonsurgical treatment.
That was one program in one country, set up by an insurer, so the numbers won’t match every situation. It is still a strong reason not to skip a second look.
What to ask
- Which level and which side is causing my symptoms, and does the MRI match where I feel it?
- What nonsurgical treatment would you try first, and for how long?
- Why this operation rather than a smaller one?
- What happens if I wait?
Our guide How to read your MRI report explains the common spine terms.
How an online second opinion works
You share the MRI images, the report and the recommendation you received, and a surgeon reviews them and writes back. BoneArc lets you choose that orthopedic surgeon from profiles and see their price first, and you get a signed written opinion plus one follow-up question. It does not include an exam, so if the opinion differs from the first, an in-person visit is the usual next step.
Quick answers
Should I get a second opinion before spine surgery?
For planned spine surgery, yes, it is reasonable and common. A 485-patient study found the second opinion disagreed with the first diagnosis in 59.8% of cases.
Can a spine second opinion be done online?
A surgeon can review your MRI, report and history remotely and give a written opinion. It does not replace an exam, and urgent symptoms need in-person care.
Do most herniated disks need surgery?
No. The AAOS says most people with a herniated disk feel better within weeks or months without surgery.
Want a surgeon to look at your scan?
BoneArc Second Opinion is a written opinion from an orthopedic surgeon on the X-ray, MRI or CT you already have. It is opening soon. Join the free waitlist and we will email you when it opens in your state.
Join the BoneArc Second Opinion waitlist →Sources
- AAOS OrthoInfo: Herniated disk in the lower back
- Lenza et al., Second opinion for degenerative spinal conditions, BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders 2017
